I-Team: Gun Rights Protect Against Government Tyranny - 8 News NOW

Guns of Nevada

I-Team: Gun Rights Protect Against Government Tyranny

Posted: Updated:

Ed. Note: The national debate about gun violence and gun control has generated strong emotions on all sides following the recent tragedies in Connecticut and Colorado. Should Americans' Second Amendment rights be restricted in the interests of public safety, or is gun violence something that no law could curb? This is Part 3 of Guns of Nevada.

LAS VEGAS -- The spike in background checks and gun sales comes at a time when the U.S. Congress is considering new gun control laws in the wake of deadly mass shootings like the one at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Conn., last December.

Passionate defenders of the Second Amendment say that the ultimate reason our gun rights must be protected is so the public can defend itself against government tyranny.

If necessary, they would take up arms against the government.

"Generally thinking, in American history, they have been few and far between," said College of Southern Nevada history professor Michael Green in response to whether the government would come for citizens' guns.

Nevada Gun Poll Results

Green said armed rebellions against the U.S. government are rare occurrences. One that stands out is the Civil War, and even with a vast army, that didn't work out well for the rebels. Green agrees that the confiscation of guns by government is the event that could most likely spark an uprising, but said Americans have always lived with gun controls, even in the Wild West.

"Since the beginnings of American history, there have been gun control laws," he said. "Mostly local. And sometimes it was: Yes, you are required to have a gun, but you might be required to have only a certain kind of gun."

Dodge City, Kan., has a sign that reads: Turn in your guns.

Why did they fight the gunfight at the O.K. Corral in Tombstone, Ariz.? The Clantons wouldn't give up their guns. And Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday were trying to run that town and they were determined.

Former police officer and gun rights advocate Randy Mackie said he thinks a rebellion is unlikely, but that gun rights could be the spark.

"Do I see it coming? No," Mackie said. "Is it possible? Yes."

"Actually the founders wrote the Second Amendment so the federal government wouldn't have a monopoly on military force.

"They sincerely believed and wanted a situation where literally the federal government wouldn't be able to muster a big enough standing army to oppose the body of the people. (Revolutionary) Patrick Henry said the ultimate goal is that every man be armed. They saw that as the best defense of the U.S. They have gotten away from that."

Gun control activist Brian Fadie said he favors tighter gun laws, but not confiscation. He said he thinks gun owners who think they could wage a guerilla war against the government are fooling themselves.

"They are promoting a scenario in which a tyrannical force takes over our government and is going to take your guns," Fadie said. "If that were to happen -- if a force were to take over our government -- what would they send to take your guns?

"Would they send an EPA agent, would they send a Department of Housing agent? No, they would send the military, the U.S. military. The most powerful fighting force on the planet. Now you are getting in to the range of having a personal arsenal in which you are able to defeat the most powerful fighting force on the planet. It would really get ridiculous pretty quickly."

Hopefully, it's a theory we never have to test.

Though an armed rebellion might sound far-fetched, U.S. troops have been questioned by their superiors in the past whether they would be willing to use force against American citizens, and if so, under what circumstances.

Mackie said one reason he and others oppose plans for greater background checks is that such a system might help the government put together a master list of all gun owners, as a step toward confiscation.

  • Guns of NevadaMore>>

  • I-Team: Former Gun Dealer Supports Background Checks

    I-Team: Former Gun Dealer Supports Background Checks

    Friday, May 3 2013 4:16 PM EDT2013-05-03 20:16:25 GMT
    LAS VEGAS -- An effort to require universal background checks for all guns sales failed in the Senate last month by six votes. Opponents of the bill insist it will not keep guns from criminals or theMore>>
    An effort to require universal background checks for all guns sales failed in the Senate last month by six votes.More>>
  • I-Team: High School Senior Deals in Arms Trade

    I-Team: High School Senior Deals in Arms Trade

    Friday, May 3 2013 8:48 PM EDT2013-05-04 00:48:15 GMT
    LAS VEGAS -- Logan Smith's backyard is in the hills bordering southwest Las Vegas where he likes to do target practice. His prized possession: an AK-47 assault rifle he recently bought on armslist.com. Armslist.comMore>>
    Logan Smith's backyard is in the hills bordering southwest Las Vegas where he likes to do target practice. His prized possession: an AK-47 assault rifle he recently bought on armslist.com.More>>
  • I-Team: Studies Conflict on Video Game Violence

    I-Team: Studies Conflict on Video Game Violence

    Thursday, May 2 2013 2:00 AM EDT2013-05-02 06:00:07 GMT
    LAS VEGAS -- America is a violent nation. Studies show the rate of death by gunfire in our country is much higher than most of the civilized world, but defenders of the Second Amendment say guns are notMore>>
    America is a violent nation. Studies show the rate of death by gunfire in our country is much higher than most of the civilized world, but defenders of the Second Amendment say guns are not the root cause of violence here.More>>
  • Guns of Nevada: The Mental Health DebateMore>>

  • I-Team: High Percentage of Jail Population Suffer Mental Issues

    I-Team: High Percentage of Jail Population Suffer Mental Issues

    Wednesday, March 27 2013 8:02 PM EDT2013-03-28 00:02:59 GMT
    Gun rights advocates say mental illness is the real reason behind mass murder incidents. There are strong indications that most, if not all, of the killers in recent mass murders had severe mental or emotional issues.More>>
    Nevada is notoriously stingy when it comes to support for mental health services. It already ranked among the worst in the nation for mental health programs, and then another $80 million was chopped during the past few years.More>>
  • Experts Debate Impact of Violent Video Games

    Experts Debate Impact of Violent Video Games

    Thursday, May 2 2013 2:00 AM EDT2013-05-02 06:00:07 GMT
    By Steve Kanigher The Sandy Hook Elementary School massacre in December rekindled a national debate over the extent, if any, to which violent video games set off individuals who go on deadly shootingMore>>
    By Steve Kanigher The Sandy Hook Elementary School massacre in December rekindled a national debate over the extent, if any, to which violent video games set off individuals who go on deadly shootingMore>>
  • Mental Health Experts Push Debate on Gun Control

    Mental Health Experts Push Debate on Gun Control

    Wednesday, April 10 2013 7:25 PM EDT2013-04-10 23:25:17 GMT
    LAS VEGAS -- Caregivers of the mentally ill say the debate in Congress cannot end with background checks. Gun control is one of many hot topics Wednesday at a national mental health conference in LasMore>>
    Caregivers of the mentally ill say the debate in Congress cannot end with background checks.More>>
  • Different Perspectives on Mental Health and Gun Violence

    Different Perspectives on Mental Health and Gun Violence

    Monday, April 1 2013 4:10 PM EDT2013-04-01 20:10:39 GMT
    LAS VEGAS -- Much is being aired and written in the national media about whether an increased investment in mental health care would have any impact on reducing gun violence. Here are examples of thoseMore>>
    Much is being aired and written in the national media about whether an increased investment in mental health care would have any impact on reducing gun violence.More>>
  • Proposed State Mental Health Budget Includes New Division

    Proposed State Mental Health Budget Includes New Division

    Monday, April 1 2013 2:57 PM EDT2013-04-01 18:57:30 GMT
    LAS VEGAS -- One highlight of Nevada's proposed mental health budget for the two-year period beginning in July is that it will belong to a newly reorganized agency called the Division of Public and BehavioralMore>>
    One highlight of Nevada's proposed mental health budget for the two-year period beginning in July is that it will belong to a newly reorganized agency called the Division of Public and Behavioral Health.More>>
  • Plan Envisioned Early Mental Health Intervention For Children

    Plan Envisioned Early Mental Health Intervention For Children

    Monday, April 1 2013 2:55 PM EDT2013-04-01 18:55:22 GMT
    LAS VEGAS -- A plan that outlined ways to improve mental health services for Nevada's children through 2020 recommended a radical shift in funding priorities from intense intervention for those with severeMore>>
    A plan that outlined ways to improve mental health services for Nevada's children through 2020 recommended a radical shift in funding priorities from intense intervention for those with severe problems to early prevention and intervention efforts.More>>
  • Taking a Closer Look at Mass Murders

    Taking a Closer Look at Mass Murders

    Monday, April 1 2013 2:52 PM EDT2013-04-01 18:52:21 GMT
    LAS VEGAS -- The Federal Bureau of Investigation defines a mass murder as generally involving at least four victims in a single location with no cooling-off period between the fatalities. But not allMore>>
    The Federal Bureau of Investigation defines a mass murder as generally involving at least four victims in a single location with no cooling-off period between the fatalities. But not all mass murderers or alleged perpetrators are alike.More>>
  • Nevada Mental Health Services Face Hurdles

    Nevada Mental Health Services Face Hurdles

    Monday, April 1 2013 2:51 PM EDT2013-04-01 18:51:44 GMT
    LAS VEGAS -- As the economic recession took its toll on Nevada, the pain of state budget cuts deeply impacted mental health services. A "Needs Assessment" issued last year by the Nevada Division of MentalMore>>
    As the economic recession took its toll on Nevada, the pain of state budget cuts deeply impacted mental health services.More>>
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and KLAS. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.