Eyewitnesses May be Unreliable in Costco Shooting - 8 News NOW

Eyewitnesses May be Unreliable in Costco Shooting

Posted: Updated:

LAS VEGAS -- As the investigation continues into the Costco officer involved shooting that killed Erik Scott, a number of witness statements conflict with those reported by Las Vegas police.

Witness statements are valuable to police, but they also have drawbacks. A local defense attorney says in scenes like this, there's only one real eyewitness who will tell the real truth: cameras.

Before 39-year-old Scott was shot and killed by three officers Saturday afternoon, did he pull out a gun? Did officers give Scott enough time to comply before shooting? Metro says yes, but a number of witness statements are suggesting something else happened.

"I'm not surprised that there's a lot of varying accounts of what happened," said attorney Joel Mann.

Mann says in situations where emotions are high and adrenaline is running, our memories aren't the most reliable.

"I think what society as a whole believes is that our memory is like a video tape, where we can rewind it and show the same thing over again, which is just not true," he said.

Complicating matters even more, Mann says witness statements can often be influenced by environment or by even other witnesses at the same scene, which could make it tough to find the truth.

Metro says during scenes like the Costco shooting, witnesses are separated and interviewed individually by homicide detectives.

In the end, Mann says, there can only be one true eyewitness. "If there are things like surveillance tapes or other objective recording devices that can't be influenced by memory or perception, then we'll probably have a better more accurate depiction of what happened," he said. "If it's based solely on eyewitnesses, we will never really know for certain what happened."

There are surveillance cameras inside of the store, but during a tour of the parking lot none were seen outside, which could be an issue since the shooting happened outside near the entrance.

Police have not released the surveillance video or 911 calls related to the incident.

  • Las Vegas NewsLas Vegas NewsMore>>

  • BREAKING NEWS: Adrian Peterson placed on exempt list by Minnesota Vikings

    BREAKING NEWS: Adrian Peterson placed on exempt list by Minnesota Vikings

    Wednesday, September 17 2014 2:26 AM EDT2014-09-17 06:26:16 GMT
    MINNEAPOLIS (AP) -- The Minnesota Vikings have placed star running back Adrian Peterson on the exempt/commissioner's permission list, a move that will require him to stay away from the team while he addresses child abuse charges.The Vikings made the announcement early Wednesday morning after initially deciding that Peterson could play with the team while the legal process played out. Peterson is charged with a felony for using a wooden switch to spank his 4-year-old son.The Vikings came under...More>>
    MINNEAPOLIS (AP) -- The Minnesota Vikings have placed star running back Adrian Peterson on the exempt/commissioner's permission list, a move that will require him to stay away from the team while he addresses child abuse charges.The Vikings made the announcement early Wednesday morning after initially deciding that Peterson could play with the team while the legal process played out. Peterson is charged with a felony for using a wooden switch to spank his 4-year-old son.The Vikings came under...More>>
  • Las Vegas mom sues over device that electronically disables car

    Las Vegas mom sues over device that electronically disables car

    Tuesday, September 16 2014 11:43 PM EDT2014-09-17 03:43:35 GMT
    They are calling it a "dangerous and illegal" practice of vehicle repossession. In this case, cars are not being towed, they're being disabled electronically.More>>
    They are calling it a "dangerous and illegal" practice of vehicle repossession. In this case, cars are not being towed, they're being disabled electronically.More>>
  • FEMA team tours flood damaged areas in Southern Nevada

    FEMA team tour flood damaged areas in Southern Nevada

    Tuesday, September 16 2014 10:46 PM EDT2014-09-17 02:46:24 GMT
    Representatives from the Federal Emergency Management Agency or FEMA spent Tuesday assessing the damage from extreme flooding in Moapa and Overton.More>>
    Representatives from the Federal Emergency Management Agency or FEMA spent Tuesday assessing the damage from extreme flooding in Moapa and Overton.More>>
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and KLAS. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.